| | Preliminary MSCS Audit Report |
|
| The much-anticipated preliminary findings of the state-funded audit of MSCS were released this week during a press conference headlined by Lt. Governor Randy McNally and Speaker Cameron Sexton. The audit covered FY2022 - FY2024 and found significant systemwide challenges in governance, internal controls, documentation, and procurement practices, including: |
|
| Weak internal controls and inconsistent adherence to policies Gaps in procurement, vendor management, and financial oversight Fragmented systems for tracking and managing contracts, finance, HR, IT, and data Limited/missing documentation and recordkeeping to prove compliance Leadership and organizational instability impacting operational effectiveness High risk for inefficiency, mismanagement, and lack of accountability $1.15M in confirmed waste/abuse (primarily in contracts) $1.73M in noncompliant spending violating internal policies
|
|
| While instances of waste and noncompliance were identified, the broader takeaway is that these issues reflect systemic breakdowns in governance, coordination, and infrastructure, rather than isolated incidents.
Though the audit is only 25% complete, Lt. Gov. Randy McNally said that he believes the waste and abuse findings may result in criminal charges related to fraud. Additional headlines from the report include that the District could not locate and provide 100 out of 250 employee Forms I-9 for compliance due to the disorganized state of documents. The audit also included photos of those records that were stored in a room “secured only by a curtain.” Additional anomalies were observed around the Herbert STEM Center’s construction, which lacked a formal written agreement with the District, resulting in undocumented expectations related to the project’s scope, roles, and responsibilities.
Tennessee Comptroller of the Treasury Jason Mumpower summarized the findings in remarks to the Commercial Appeal: “There is an absolute culture of apathy and carelessness within the Memphis Shelby County School System. There is at no level an expectation that things are done right. The Board of Education, the leadership in the school system, does not know, and has not ever exhibited an expectation that things are done right.”
Democratic members of the General Assembly representing parts of Shelby County quickly pointed out the fact that $1.1 million in potential waste or abuse represents less than 1% of the District’s more than $2 billion budget, which has little to do with the experience of a child in a classroom. Others believe that the findings are intentionally being utilized to justify the state’s intervention in MSCS, which had already been planned before the audit. Senator Brent Taylor, the sponsor of the Senate version of the intervention bill, emphasized that his plan is not for a “state takeover,” but rather an authorization of local intervention, made up of local Memphians to intervene “to try to turn our school system around.” |
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Regardless of whether the state ultimately intervenes, this moment underscores a broader reality: the current approach is not consistently delivering the outcomes our children and community deserve. Addressing the audit findings and the systemic challenges that have long plagued the district are essential to renew public trust and strengthen the effectiveness of our school system. Dr. Richmond, the recently appointed permanent MSCS superintendent, has stated he is committed to continuing to work with the state on addressing the identified findings and has already begun working on these improvements. For transparency, the district plans to share on Monday, April 6, their progress in addressing the audit findings. |
|
| School Finance Best Practices |
|
| A recent survey of school administrators, conducted by EdWeek to determine best practices in school financing, found that an early and intentional approach to identifying priorities each budget cycle is necessary for the smooth functioning of a district. The last-minute nature of budget negotiations in many school districts often leads to confusion, inefficiencies, and reliance on unnecessary third-party contracts that are often compounded in districts that have frequent leadership turnover, such as MSCS.
Additionally, EdWeek found that strong districts ensure that budget priorities and decisions are tightly aligned with their strategic plan and academic goals. Resources should be directed toward programs and interventions that demonstrate measurable impact on student outcomes. At the same time, it is important to regularly assess long-standing investments and partnerships to ensure they are delivering the intended value. Lastly, maintaining complete, accurate, and accessible financial records is not optional; it is critical to accountability, compliance, and long-term sustainability.
This performance-based approach should be implemented in a timely and meticulous manner each budget cycle to continue building a more coordinated, transparent, and outcomes-driven system that better serves children and families. |
|
|
| At the end of the day, the most important measure of a school district’s effectiveness is the quality of academics and performance of its students. While external factors in a child’s life—housing, health, food, etc.—contribute significantly to their ability to excel academically, identifying the right priorities to address collectively as a community is critical to the success of not only our schools but our community as a whole.
Seeding Success recognizes the seriousness of the recent audit findings and the urgency of this moment for our community. As an organization focused on improving cradle-to-career outcomes for children in Memphis and Shelby County, we understand that strong, effective systems are essential to ensuring every child has the opportunity to succeed. When there are gaps in alignment, transparency, or execution, the impact is felt not just within schools but across the entire community.
We have been a long-term committed partner to MSCS and to the hundreds of organizations and leaders working to support children and families throughout Shelby County. Through our collective impact efforts, we have developed a deep understanding of both the system's complexity and the importance of strong coordination, clear processes, and shared accountability. The findings from this audit underscore the immediate need to strengthen how systems operate, how resources are managed, and how efforts are aligned to support students effectively. This is a critical moment, and it calls for focus, collaboration, and a commitment from our entire community to build a high-performing district.
Seeding Success stands ready to support this work. We believe that by working collectively, Memphis can build stronger systems that better serve children and families. We remain committed to supporting the district, our broader community, and the state as we move forward, because this alignment is necessary to ensure every student has access to the opportunities they need to succeed and to ensure our school system is equipped to serve our children and community effectively. |
|
|
| | | |
|
|
|
|
|
